Changing Frames
Rivers, rain and moving trains: velocities as seen by different observers.
Lesson at a glanceShow the key points
- Position: r(P,S) = r(P,S′) + r(S′,S); velocity: v(P,S) = v(P,S′) + v(S′,S).
- The velocity of body 1 relative to body 2 is v₁ − v₂, both measured in a common frame.
- To cross a river straight, head upstream at sin φ = v(river)/v(swimmer); impossible if the swimmer is slower than the river.
- Frames moving uniformly relative to each other measure the same acceleration.
- These rules hold for translating frames at speeds far below the speed of light.
Position, velocity and acceleration all depend on who is measuring. This lesson gives the rules for translating between observers, and explains why you tilt your umbrella when you run through rain.
Positions in two frames
Let frames S and S′ watch the same particle P. The frames may be moving relative to each other. With O and O′ their origins, the position of P relative to S is and relative to S′ is , while the position of S′ itself (its origin) relative to S is . The triangle rule links them:
Velocities in two frames
Differentiate (3.26) with respect to time:
The velocity of the particle relative to S is its velocity relative to S′ plus the velocity of S′ relative to S. Rearranged, it answers the everyday question “how fast is A moving as seen from B?”:
Two everyday cases. A rifle fires bullets at 80 m/s relative to the rifle. Mounted on a train moving at 25 m/s and fired forward, the bullet moves at 80 + 25 = 105 m/s relative to the ground. And a swimmer who manages 1.5 m/s in still water (that is, relative to the water) swimming with a 1.0 m/s current moves at 2.5 m/s relative to the bank.
A swimmer can swim at 1.2 m/s in still water. She crosses a river flowing at 0.9 m/s, always keeping her body pointed straight across (perpendicular to the current, relative to the water). What is her velocity relative to the bank?
Rain falls vertically at 12 km/h. You walk along a level road at 5 km/h. Find the velocity of the rain relative to you.
Accelerations in two frames
Differentiate once more:
If S′ moves relative to S at constant velocity, then and . Observers drifting past each other uniformly disagree about positions and velocities, but they agree about accelerations. That fact will become the foundation of Newton’s laws in the chapters ahead.
- 1, and the same pattern for velocity and acceleration.
- 2Velocity of 1 relative to 2: (both measured in a common frame).
- 3Frames moving uniformly relative to each other measure the same acceleration.
- 4Valid for translating frames at everyday speeds (far below the speed of light).
Check yourself
Keep exploring
Hand-picked videos, simulations and readings that explain this idea from a different angle.