Magnetometers
M/B_H from deflection, MB_H from oscillation.
Lesson at a glanceShow the key points
- Tan-A: M/B_H = (4π/μ₀)(d² − l²)² tan θ/2d (36.21); Tan-B: (4π/μ₀)(d² + l²)^(3/2) tan θ (36.22).
- Null method compares moments; cot θ plots verify inverse square; B_H1/B_H2 = tan θ₂/tan θ₁.
- Oscillation magnetometer: T = 2π√(I/MB_H) (36.23), MB_H = 4π²I/T² (36.24).
- M = √(XY), B_H = √(Y/X) with X = M/B_H, Y = MB_H.
Two simple instruments, one measuring M/BH and one measuring MBH, together pin down both the strength of a magnet and the Earth’s horizontal field.
The deflection magnetometer
A small compass with a pointer over a 0°–90° scale (with a mirror against parallax), in a box mounted on a wooden frame with two long arms carrying metre scales that read distance from the needle’s centre. Its job is to measure M/BH for a bar magnet, in one of two standard positions.
Tan-A position
Arms along magnetic east–west, pointer at 0°–0°. Lay the magnet along an arm, centre at distance d. The needle is end-on, so the magnet’s field (east or west) is perpendicular to BH; the tangent law gives
Tan-B position
Arms along magnetic north–south; the magnet lies across an arm, symmetric about it. Now the needle is broadside-on, the field again east–west:
Errors are removed by averaging 16 readings: both ends of the pointer (off-centre pivot), the magnet reversed end for end (magnetic centre ≠ geometric centre), turned upside down (magnetic axis ≠ geometric axis), and placed on the other arm (scale zero ≠ needle centre).
A magnet of magnetic length 8.0 cm, its centre 20 cm from the needle in Tan-A position, gives a deflection of 45°. Find M/BH.
Uses
- Comparing two magnets by the null method: put one magnet on each arm and adjust distances until the needle doesn’t deflect; their fields at the needle are then equal. In Tan-B with short magnets, M₁/M₂ = d₁³/d₂³. No angle is measured, so it is both easier and more sensitive.
- Testing the inverse-square law: in Tan-A, cot θ ∝ 2d/(d² − l²)², so plotting cot θ against (d² − l²)²/2d should give a straight line through the origin (in Tan-B, against (d² + l²)^(3/2)). Since these formulas come from B ∝ m/r² for a pole, the straight line verifies it.
- Comparing BH at two places: same magnet, same d: BH1/BH2 = tan θ₂/tan θ₁.
Two short magnets on opposite arms in Tan-B position give no deflection when they are 20 cm and 25 cm from the needle. Compare their moments.
The oscillation magnetometer
A glass-walled box with a mirror on its base and a reference line along the middle; a hanger on an unspun silk thread from a torsion head. Level it, turn the box so the reference line lies in the magnetic meridian (check with a compass), take the twist out of the thread with a brass bar, then hang the magnet, north end north, and set it swinging gently.
Displaced by θ, the magnet feels a restoring torque −MBH sin θ ≈ −MBHθ (ignoring the thread’s twist). With moment of inertia I, that is angular SHM:
A compass needle makes 20 oscillations a minute where the dip is 30°, and 24 a minute where the dip is 50°. Compare the total field at the two places.
Finding M and the horizontal field separately
With X = M/BH from a deflection magnetometer and Y = MBH from an oscillation magnetometer:
The magnet above (M/BH = 3.69 × 10⁴ A m²/T) has I = 2.9 × 10⁻⁵ kg m² and oscillates with T = 5.0 s. Find M and BH.
- 1Deflection magnetometer: M/B_H from Tan-A (36.21) or Tan-B (36.22) with the tangent law.
- 2Null method compares moments; cot θ plots verify the inverse-square law; tan θ ratios compare B_H.
- 3Oscillation magnetometer: T = 2π√(I/MB_H) (36.23).
- 4M = √(XY), B_H = √(Y/X).
Check yourself
Keep exploring
Hand-picked videos, simulations and readings that explain this idea from a different angle.